THE G.I. FACTOR: ANSWERED QUESTIONS
What sort of variation do we see from day-to-day and between people?
G.I. values show a certain degree of variability, both from day to day and between people. In non-diabetic subjects, the average day-to-day variation is 22 per cent (ie the G.L value varies by an average of 22 per cent). In people with type 2 diabetes, it is 16 per cent, but in individuals with type 1 diabetes, it is as high as 30 per cent. This means we should not expect to see precisely the same blood sugar levels after one particular food from one day to the next.
As is the case with any biological response there is quite wide variation between subjects ie the G.I. in one person may be double that in another. However, it is dear that subjects tend to ‘track’ well, giving high or low or intermediate responses on a consistent basis. In practice, therefore, foods will show the same ranking in terms of G.I. factor in different subjects.
Why are there different G.I. values for the same food in different publications?
In some instances, there is a difference between two results but it is small and not statistically or biologically important. For example, G.I. factors of 70 and 80 for white bread are not considered very different. The difference is within the error of the methodology. A difference of 20 units, say 60 and 80, is considered important in a clinical sense and is usually statistically significant as well.
There may also be differences due to variations in the food itself. Rice is a good example of this. Genetically determined differences in the amylose content of rice means that different varieties of rice have very different G.I. factors. Basmati rice has a low G.I. factor and Calrose rice has a high G.I. factor. In the early days of G.I. research, the variety of rice was not specified.
Again, the same food processed in different ways can produce very different G.I. factors. Breads containing a lot of intact whole grains will have a lower G.I. factor than normal soft white sandwich bread. Packaged breakfast cereals, on the other hand, are processed in similar ways all over the world and their G.I. factors are very similar in Canada, Australia and elsewhere.
A third reason for the differences is the use of two reference foods, bread or glucose. However, it is easy to convert from one scale to the other using the factor 1.4 (equals 100/70). For example, if the G.I. factor of a food is 80 when bread is the reference food, its G.I. factor on a scale where glucose equals 100, is 80 divided by 1.4 (equals 57).
*88\42\4*
Posted by admin on May 8th, 2009 :: Filed under Diabetes